Buyer Beware: 11 Bad Generic Products That Failed To Impress • Guide2Free

This post may contain affiliate links that earn me a small commission, at no cost to you. As always, I only recommend links I personally use and love!

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Email SMS

Today we delve into the realm of generics, sharing the cautionary tales of Reddit users who refuse to buy certain products in generic form. From food items to household essentials, their experiences shed light on the potential pitfalls of going generic. So, before you reach for that store-brand version, let’s explore these 11 products that have left Redditors feeling unsatisfied.

Doritos: The Authenticity That Can’t Be Compromised

A Reddit user shares an amusing anecdote about their strong reaction to their husband bringing home off-brand Doritos, exclaiming, “My husband one time brought home off-brand Doritos. I could’ve strangled him. Tasted like tortilla chips sprinkled with LIES.” This humorous statement illustrates their unwavering loyalty to the original Doritos brand. They emphasize the disappointment they felt upon trying the generic version, describing it as a far cry from the genuine Doritos experience.

Feminine Products: Not All Are Created Equal

One Reddit user expresses their strong aversion to purchasing generic or store-brand feminine products, saying, “Feminine products (pads/tampons). Don’t even get me started on the no-name brands or store brands… When it comes to this stuff, you definitely get what you pay for.” According to them, the quality of these products is directly tied to their price, and they firmly believe that opting for well-known brands is essential.

Ketchup: Quality Matters

One Reddit user adamantly refuses to buy generic ketchup, stating, “Ketchup. Seriously… all of the store-brand stuff is all sugar and no vinegar!” They argue that generic ketchup tends to prioritize sweetness over the classic tanginess that comes from the right balance of vinegar and sugar. According to them, opting for well-known brands ensures a superior flavor profile and a more satisfying culinary experience.

Mac and Cheese: The Unbeatable Taste of Kraft Dinner

mac cheese kraft dinner — Photo Credit: Juliedeshaies / Deposit Photos

When it comes to mac and cheese, one Reddit user firmly believes that no generic brand can surpass the taste of Kraft Dinner. They confidently state, “Mac and Cheese. Never came across a generic brand that tasted better than Kraft Dinner.” According to them, Kraft Dinner sets the bar high with its unique flavor and creamy texture, making it the go-to choice for a satisfying and nostalgic mac and cheese experience.

Cereal: The Unmatched Taste of Name Brands

One Reddit user staunchly asserts their preference for name-brand cereals, stating, “Cereal. I don’t care what anyone says, cereal tastes different when it’s generic.” According to their experience, there is a noticeable difference in taste between generic and name-brand cereals. They firmly believe that opting for name brands ensures a unique and superior flavor that cannot be replicated by generic alternatives.

Toilet Paper: Store Brands Don’t Measure Up

When it comes to toilet paper, one Reddit user vividly describes their dissatisfaction with store brands, stating, “Toilet paper. Store brands are pretty close to bark and thorns.” According to their experience, generic toilet paper falls significantly short in terms of quality and comfort. They believe that opting for well-known brands ensures a far superior toilet paper experience, avoiding the unpleasantness that can come with using subpar alternatives.

Q-tips: The Frustration of Generic Alternatives

One Reddit user expresses their frustration with generic Q-tips, exclaiming, “Oh my god, I will never again buy generic Q-tips. Might as well just jam toothpicks in your ears for all the good the minuscule amount of cotton on the ends does.” According to their experience, generic Q-tips fail to provide the desired level of functionality and effectiveness. They argue that the small amount of cotton on the ends is insufficient, likening it to the inadequate experience of using toothpicks instead.

Oreos: Accept No Imitations

When it comes to Oreos, one Reddit user firmly believes that there’s no substitute for the original or double-stuffed versions. They express their preference, stating, “Oreos… has to be either regular or double stuff. The generic stuff isn’t the same.” According to their experience, generic alternatives fail to capture the unique taste, texture, and satisfaction that come with genuine Oreos.

Pudding: Quality Matters for a Creamy Delight

When it comes to pudding, one Reddit user holds a strong aversion to purchasing generic brands. They specifically highlight their preference, stating, “Pudding. There’s plenty of other stuff that I refuse to buy generic of, but pudding is my number one. Generic is rubbery and jiggly and disgusting.” According to their experience, generic pudding fails to deliver the desired texture and taste. They perceive it as rubbery, overly jiggly, and ultimately unappetizing.

Cola: The Irreplaceable Classic

One Reddit user admits to experimenting with generic cola brands, but ultimately concludes, “While I’ve done it to see if there was anything as good… cola!!!” This statement reflects their unwavering loyalty to the classic cola brands. They suggest that despite trying alternatives, no generic cola can match the distinct flavor and overall experience offered by the original cola brands.

Crayons: Crayola, the Unmatched Choice for Colorful Creativity

Despite being a self-proclaimed frugal shopper who predominantly buys off-brand products, one Reddit user firmly stands by their preference for Crayola crayons. They assert, “I buy almost exclusively off-brands because I’m cheap, but when it comes to crayons, Crayola is the ONLY way to go. I refuse to use anything else, ESPECIALLY ROSE ART.” This statement reflects their unwavering loyalty to Crayola as the ultimate choice for crayon enthusiasts. They express a strong aversion to alternative brands, particularly Rose Art.